Flaky pie crust filled with apples and topped with our signature crumble topping. Pie is 9 inches.
Thanksgiving Orders: Pre-order window closes Tues 11/26 5pm for pickup on Wed 11/27. Wed 11/27 is for pre-order pickups only. No walk-ins available. Bakeries are closed Thurs 11/28 – Fri 11/29.
Serve and store at room temperature
If you love warm apple pie, put it in your oven at 325 degrees for 25 minutes
5.0 / 5.0
What our Guests are Saying
This is a carousel with customer reviews. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.
5
Well as I expected when I wrote my other review, this apple pie was well worth the wait and trip across the city to get. Simply the best apple pie I have ever had. The crumble was perfectly made and the apples so sweet and delicious with perfect texture. I am so happy that I stumbled upon Susie's Cakes and will definitely be stopping anytime we are on that side of town.
Tim A.
5
Susie cakes has the best apple pie in the business! Perfect mix of apples and a crumbly top. Please make it a year round staple!
Madison
5
The subject line sums it all up. This was the very best apple pie I've ever tasted! I went in to see if they had pumpkin pie (it was after Thanksgiving), but I'm glad they were out! This apple pie is as beautiful as it was delicious. I don't think I can really enjoy a basic apple pie anymore. The crumble surely elevates the experience. So great. Get it while it's still in season (December 24th!). I'll be back!
mike
5
So delicious!! I had to go back for seconds!
Suzanne
5
Fabulous and Delicious
Michael Russo
5
The best apple pie I've had! Top with some of the whipped cream and you have yourself an amazing dessert.