This is a carousel with product images.

Key Lime Pie
Added to Cart!
Continue Shopping Go to Cart

Key Lime Pie

(8 reviews) Write a Review

This seasonal item is no longer on the menu. Check back later!

Enjoy the tangy delight of our Key Lime Pie! With a graham cracker crust as its foundation, this pie has a vibrant key lime filling that strikes the perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness. Topped with fresh Chantilly whipped cream, every forkful delivers a harmonious blend of flavors and textures.

  • Slice — $5.95
  • Whole Pie — $34.95
$0.00
Find a bakery Click here to find your local bakery, then place your order. This product is available only in our CA and TX bakeries for pickup or local delivery.
Tap above to find your local bakery, then place your order. This product is available only in our CA and TX bakeries for pickup or local delivery.
Add to Cart The item has been added
Mixing Bowl Icon

Made Fresh Daily

Every pie is made to order using only quality ingredients.

Delivery Truck Icon

Local Delivery

We deliver locally to homes and businesses near our stores in California and Texas.

Bakery store icon

Bakery Pickup

Our cakes are made daily in our 25 bakeries, using only the freshest & finest ingredients.

4.0 / 5.0

What our Guests are Saying

This is a carousel with customer reviews. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

  • 2
    This pie has been one of my favorite go to at SC. However, i was extremely disappointed to find how much a single slice had decreased in size. Certainly no longer worth the price of a slice. I know there is an inflation, but really Susie Cakes??

    MICHELLE

  • 2
    It appears the key lime slice has gotten substantially smaller for the price!!!!

    Peaches

  • 5
    I bought a slice to try for the first time. So tasty! Tangy, sweet, fluffy & cool and refreshing! ! I love anything citrus flavored. And the crust was excellent & delicious! Coming back to buy a whole pie to share with my family

    Arthur/Park La Brea

  • 5
    The best ever!!! The service is spectacular

    tabitha winters

  • 5
    Everyone - when I say this cake fuels me on a daily basis, I am not joking. I wake up looking forward to a morning slice. I go to bed indulging in my dessert slice. All day is spent thinking about Susiecake's Key Lime. Cannot recommend higher.

    Sean Edward Homsy

  • 5
    My husband’s favorite ?

    Geri

  • 5
    Not over sweet, fluffy yet holds its shape. Best key lime pie in Long Beach.

    Shawna

  • 5
    Every year, I mark my calendar for this terrific dessert. Exactly the right blend of lime tang and sweetness.

    Nancy

Want More of a Good Thing?

Vanilla Celebration Cake
Vanilla Celebration Cake
Cake Flight
Cake Flight
Strawberry Cupcake
Strawberry Cupcake
Explore Our Menu