Added to Cart!

Old-Fashioned Chocolate

(22 reviews) Write a Review

“Just like you remember!” 4-layers of moist chocolate cake filled and covered in rich, dark chocolate buttercream frosting. This cake is a 6-inch cake. Serves 6-12 people. Also comes with a complimentary candle and matchbox!

Free shipping! (included in price)

$89.00
Add to Cart The item has been added

Selecting a Delivery Date

While we ship next-day via UPS, delivery may be delayed due to weather or other service issues. Please choose a delivery date at least 3 days before you plan to serve the cake to allow time for possible delays and the cake defrosting process. We deliver Tuesday through Friday.

For example: If you plan to serve on Saturday, select a Wednesday or earlier delivery date. See graphic above.

From Our Bakery to Your Door...

  • 1

    Made to Order

    Your cake is made to order, quickly frozen to lock in freshness, and packed in a custom cake box with dry ice.

  • 2

    Cake Delivered

    Your box will arrive right at your doorstep! Handle the dry ice with care (using oven mitts or a towel). All our packaging and insulation is recyclable!

  • 3

    Defrosting Process

    Place the wrapped cake in the refrigerator overnight. If you received your cake early, you can keep the cake in the freezer until you're ready to start the defrosting process.

  • 4

    Serve & Enjoy!

    On the day of your celebration, remove the cake from the fridge, unwrap, and place the cake on your counter at least 4 hours before serving. Our cakes are best served at room temperature.

Made to Order
Made to Order
Decorative background image

Susie's Guarantee

At SusieCakes®, we create more meaningful connections by elevating milestones and turning everyday occasions into unforgettable memories; and we do this by baking the best-tasting timeless versions of your most loved desserts.

We know how important those moments are and we feel privileged to be a part of these special times, which is why we guarantee the quality of our desserts upon delivery. This guarantee ensures the dessert should look beautiful (no smashed cakes on Susie’s watch!) and taste amazing (delicious and moist), as long as the serving directions are followed.

Classic Ingredients

We bake using simple, back to basics ingredients, just like you would find in an old-fashioned pantry.

  • Creamy Butter

    Creamy Butter

  • Whole Milk

    Whole Milk

  • Fresh Eggs

    Fresh Eggs

  • All Purpose Flour

    ALl Purpose Flour

  • Chocolate Buttercream

    Chocolate Buttercream

  • Granulated Sugar

    Granulated Sugar

We absolutley enjoyed our cake! I had never had a cake shipped to me and I worried about a frozen cake thawing and being dry. Boy was I wrong! It tasted fresh and creamy! The moisture held perfectly and it was delicious! Highly recommend and let the shipping worries go! She's got a system down!

Heidi L.

5.0 / 5.0

What our Guests are Saying

This is a carousel with customer reviews. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

  • 5
    I'm typically not a big chocolate person and I couldn't get enough of this cake. YUM!

    Mike

  • 5
    We absolutely enjoyed our cake! I had never had a cake shipped to me and I worried about a frozen cake thawing out and being dry. Boy was I wrong! It tasted fresh and creamy! The moisture held perfectly and it was delicious! Highly recommend and let the shipping worries go! She’s got a system down!

    Heidi L

  • 5
    This cake arrived expertly packaged and with perfect happy birthday lettering on the top. It defrosted easily overnight and was ready to enjoy the next evening. Could not ask for a better birthday cake experience!! Will order again! Xoxo for a great cake!

    Audrey R

  • 5
    The cake was perfectly packaged and shipped. Once it defrosted, the texture of the cake and frosting was as if I walked into my local SusieCakes and picked it up. Absolutely delicious! This was my first time trying the Old Fashioned Chocolate and it’s easily one of my faves now.

    AM

  • 5
    DELICIOUS! This cake was amazing. Moist, rich chocolate and creamy frosting. Nothing can beat old fashioned chocolate cake.

    Maggie Ivy

  • 5
    It's always stressful shipping food, but SusieCakes knocked it out of the park! Their attention to detail in everything was amazing- the packaging, the instructions, the DELICIOUS cake, the little celebration elements inside- a wonderful way to celebrate loved ones! We love you Susie!

    Rachel

  • 5
    Everything was perfect about this cake: DELICIOUS FLAVOR, moist, beautiful, tall, dense! It's truly a gift -- and it comes in the cutest packaging! Send one -- and make someone's day!

    Lisa C.

  • 5
    Wow...was this cake amazing! Going to be ordering this many times more for myself and friends!

    Jeff B.

  • 5
    I had such a great experience with the cake being shipped. I was amazed how it was so perfect when it arrived. The cake tasted great! Great experience!!!

    Dana