Sweetheart Sandwich

(3 reviews) Write a Review

Sorry, this item is no longer on the menu!

Available only through Sunday! A charming treat made with two soft, buttery sugar cookies generously filled with rich vanilla buttercream. Each sandwich is topped with a festive sprinkle of colorful confetti, adding a touch of whimsy and sweetness — $4.75 each

Current Stock:

$0.00

Find a bakery Click here to find your local bakery, then place your order. This product is available only in our CA and TX bakeries for pickup or local delivery. Add to Cart The item has been added

5.0 / 5.0

5

These are hands down the best cookies ever. Actual perfection and the GOAT of desserts. The best frosting ever with the best cookie ever. Please bring back and complete me.

For the love of cookie, BRING BACK
5

This was my absolute favorite item from Susie Cakes. Please bring these morsels of delight back to the menu. It's rare that you see a great sprinkle sugar cookie done well and you all nailed it. I'm always craving it.

Leslie
5

This is one of my favorite items on the menu. These are best cookies and they are hearty. I have written so many emails requesting that they put this back on the menu since it disappeared due to a lower menu during the pandemic. These and their lemon bars are two of my favorites. I never leave the bakery without either. The sugar cookie base is soft and buttery. The filling is the same buttercream filling that is on the buttercream cakes. It reminds me of a nice thumbprint/buttercream cookie. Thank you for bringing back, even if only for a moment. Put it back on full time please.

DW