This seasonal item is no longer on the menu. Check back later!
Susie’s exclusive! Two thick, chewy chocolate cookies sandwiched with vanilla buttercream—$8.25 each(sold online in boxes of 4)
5.0 / 5.0
What our Guests are Saying
This is a carousel with customer reviews. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.
5
These are my favorite both chocolate and pb please bring them back permanently. Otherwise, I have no reason to come in to buy other goodies.
Virginia
5
Please bring these back permanently. They are as good as your classic vanilla cupcake. Pls don’t take them from us ever. Or start selling the recipe so we can get our fix outside of your season!
Marisa
5
Please, please, PLEASE bring these back permanently, or at least semi-regularly! I used to get these all the time, they are the absolute best. And then they’ve been discontinued?! My absolute favorite treat from anywhere? I was a steady customer every month! (You guessed it, this was my PMS treat every time). Sure, the cookies are great, but in all honesty, I stopped coming to Susie’s for my monthly fix ever since the whoopie pies were discontinued. And I don’t need cakes very often. The whoopie pie is my favorite, and I honestly don’t like them anywhere else. Please bring them back!
Hayley
5
When are you bringing back the Whoopie Pies?. Hurry and bring them back.
Mario
5
Please bring back Whoopie Pies
Best ever. Better than traditional. The best. I need Whoopie Pies!
Lyle
5
Please bring back your Whoppie pies. They are the best I ever had
Maria Hill
5
Please! Would love to see these on the permanent menu again. Favorite thing you make!
Lenny
5
Please please add these back to the menu, the world is a darker place without them.
Kate
5
These are the absolute best! They need to bring them back permanently!
