Added to Cart!

Susie's Nutty Sandwich

(5 reviews) Write a Review

Two flourless peanut butter cookies sandwiched together with peanut butter buttercream. — $31.80 (box of 4)

*Please note, there is  gluten present in the bakery and in other products, and we do share equipment among products.

$0.00
Find a bakery Click here to find your local bakery, then place your order. This product is available only in our CA and TX bakeries for pickup or local delivery.
Tap above to find your local bakery, then place your order. This product is available only in our CA and TX bakeries for pickup or local delivery.
Add to Cart The item has been added

4.0 / 5.0

What our Guests are Saying

This is a carousel with customer reviews. Use the previous and next buttons to navigate.

  • 5
    Not sure how anyone could give this cookie less than 5 stars, I do not care what the price is as this was possibly the best cookie sandwich I have ever had in my 49 years of life. The cookie was perfectly soft and delicious and the creme was the perfect amount of sweet without being overly sweet. I should have bought a dozen but this makes me excited to try the apple pie I bought for later. Thank you for making my day.

    Tim Acel

  • 5
    THANK YOU SUSIE FOR BRINGING THESE BACK TO THE EVERYDAY MENU, THEYRE MY ABSOLUTE FAVORITE!!!!

    MeganMac

  • 5
    My favorite. So glad it's back on the menu now.

    Tommi

  • 2
    $8 for ONE cookie is NOT. A good value!

    Randy

  • 5
    These are so good and great value!

    Bob Flynn