

Sorry, this item left the menu on October 1st!
Susie’s exclusive! Two thick, chewy chocolate cookies sandwiched with vanilla buttercream— $6.95 each (sold online in boxes of 4)
5.0 / 5.0
Please! Would love to see these on the permanent menu again. Favorite thing you make!
Lenny
Please please add these back to the menu, the world is a darker place without them.
Kate
These are the absolute best! They need to bring them back permanently!
Dawn
My absolute favorite treat. The best whoopie pie I've ever had. They were previously a permanent item but since Covid they are not on the menu besides random pop ups. I would frequent Susiecakes way more if they brought these back.
Michelle
Pre-covid these were regulars on the menu. Shame they're gone. I'd always get 1 or two with my slice. They're delicious. Perfect whoopie pie
Rebs
Just simply, WOW. Get up and get one (or a few) right now! Chewy, Semi sweet chocolate cookies, layered with the creamy sweet buttercream, is the perfect mixture for a sugar fix!
Lily She
Best ever
Ruben martinez
Get the sweet scoop
Sign up to receive exclusive offers and be the first to know about seasonal specials, brand new treats, events and more!
TELL SUSIE
Have feedback about our products or service? Please contact Susie directly at: Susie@SusieCakes.com