Added to Cart!
Confetti Gif

Whoopie Pies

(8 reviews) Write a Review

Sorry, this item left the menu on October 1st! 

Susie’s exclusive! Two thick, chewy chocolate cookies sandwiched with vanilla buttercream $6.95 each (sold online in boxes of 4) 


5.0 / 5.0

What our Guests are Saying

  • 5

    Please bring back your Whoppie pies. They are the best I ever had

    Maria Hill

  • 5

    Please! Would love to see these on the permanent menu again. Favorite thing you make!


  • 5

    Please please add these back to the menu, the world is a darker place without them.


  • 5

    These are the absolute best! They need to bring them back permanently!


  • 5

    My absolute favorite treat. The best whoopie pie I've ever had. They were previously a permanent item but since Covid they are not on the menu besides random pop ups. I would frequent Susiecakes way more if they brought these back.


  • 5

    Pre-covid these were regulars on the menu. Shame they're gone. I'd always get 1 or two with my slice. They're delicious. Perfect whoopie pie


  • 5

    Just simply, WOW. Get up and get one (or a few) right now! Chewy, Semi sweet chocolate cookies, layered with the creamy sweet buttercream, is the perfect mixture for a sugar fix!

    Lily She

  • 5

    Best ever

    Ruben martinez